[13.0]: SUBPOENA
“ORDER TO APPEAR IN COURT TO GIVE EVIDENCE”
[13.1]: INTRODUCTION
A subpoena is a formal written order that requires a person to appear before a court or other legal proceedings (such as a Congressional hearing). The order is a demand to testify or produce documentation.
The term subpoena originates from the Middle English word suppena and the Latin phrase sub poena, which translates to "under penalty". It can also be spelled as "subpena". The concept of subpoena stems from English common law and is now widely applied across the English common law realm.
Furthermore, A subpoena is a legal tool employed to compel an individual, business, or entity to offer testimony or furnish documents and evidence pertinent to a legal case. Issued under statutory law authority, subpoenas are enforced via the court's contempt powers.
[13.2]: THE POWER TO ISSUE A SUBPOENA: WHO AND WHY:
Attorneys possess an inherent authority to issue subpoenas due to their role as officers of the court. Similarly, pro se litigants have the option to request blank subpoenas directly from the court clerk. Additionally, administrative law judges hold the power to issue subpoenas to aid in conducting hearings and investigations.
Subpoenas are utilized in situations where testimony or evidence from individuals not involved in the case is necessary to advance genuine fact-finding, substantiate arguments or defenses, explore leads, or procure exhibits for trial. Typically, courts uphold appropriately issued and served subpoenas by imposing contempt sanctions or employing alternative measures.
[13.3]: TYPES OF SUBPOENAS:
There exist two primary kinds of subpoenas:
1. Subpoena ad testificandum: This mandates an individual's presence to provide verbal testimony at a designated time and location, such as during a deposition, hearing, or trial.
2. Subpoena duces tecum: This orders a person or entity to furnish requested documents, electronically stored data, or physical evidence. For instance, a bank's custodian could be summoned to provide bank records.
While a subpoena ad testificandum requires oral testimony, a subpoena duces tecum concentrates solely on document and evidence production. However, a hybrid subpoena may incorporate elements of both types.
[13.4]: COMPLYING WITH A SUBPOENA:
If you receive a subpoena, you are legally required to comply. Options include:
1. Appear at the specified time and location to give testimony.
2. Produce the requested documents by the deadline.
3. File a motion to quash if there are legal grounds to invalidate the subpoena.
Failure to comply with a valid subpoena could potentially lead to being held in contempt of court.
So in summary, a subpoena is a vital legal instrument that ensures key evidence or testimony is obtained for legal proceedings. Understanding what a subpoena entails can help ensure proper compliance.
[13.5]: WHAT MAKES A SUBPOENA INVALID?
1. A subpoena may be deemed invalid and unenforceable if it fails to meet certain legal criteria. The primary grounds for a court to quash or modify a subpoena are:
2. Insufficient time for compliance: If the timeframe provided to produce documents or testimony is unreasonable, the court can nullify the subpoena. Factors considered include the volume of records requested and the difficulty in retrieving them.
3. Travel distance exceeding 100 miles: Individuals cannot be compelled to travel over 100 miles to comply with a subpoena, unless permitted by state law exceptions. This provision aims to prevent undue hardship.
4. Request for privileged information: Information protected by privileges such as attorney-client, doctor-patient confidentiality, or spousal privilege cannot be compelled. The court may adjust the subpoena to exclude privileged details.
5. Imposition of undue burden: A subpoena may be quashed if compliance disrupts business operations, infringes on privacy rights without justification, or imposes unreasonable costs.
Issuing a valid subpoena requires attorneys to ensure reasonable timeframes, proximity, scope of records requested, and respect for confidentiality rights. Diligently assessing these factors can help avoid the issuance of unenforceable subpoenas and prevent wastage of time and resources.
[13.6]: WHAT IS AN EXAMPLE OF A SUBPOENA?
A subpoena is frequently utilized, such as when a lawyer issues one to compel an individual's attendance in court or the submission of documents relevant to a legal matter, such as a child custody dispute. For example, in a child custody case, one spouse's attorney might subpoena the other spouse to attend court proceedings to establish custody arrangements that prioritize the child's welfare, like joint custody. Additionally, various forms of information, like blood test results, DNA samples, medical records, bank statements, and phone records, could also be subpoenaed.
[13.7]: HOW TO ISSUE A SUBPOENA: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE:
The typical steps for an attorney to issue a subpoena typically involve:
1. Identifying the necessary evidence and its sources.
2. Crafting the subpoena with precise details such as date, location, and requested materials.
3. Delivering the subpoena to the intended recipient.
4. Allowing a reasonable timeframe for compliance.
5. Taking enforcement actions if the subpoena is not adhered to.
Additionally, courts may issue subpoenas upon request from involved parties in a case, with diligence requirements in place to ensure the relevance and necessity of the requested information.
[13.8]: THE IMPORTANCE OF SUBPOENAS IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE:
On both the prosecution and defense side, subpoenas provide critical evidence in criminal cases. Prosecutors can subpoena crime lab reports, coroner’s reports, phone records, and other documents to build their case. Defense attorneys also utilize subpoenas to access records that may exonerate their client, such as alibis, communications, and forensic evidence.
In criminal matters, subpoenas help ensure justice is served by compelling the production of documentation that attorneys might not otherwise be able to obtain. Subpoenas also allow for a more transparent discovery process
[13.9]: RESPONDING TO A SUBPOENA AS A PRO SE PARTY:
If you receive a subpoena as a self-represented litigant, it's important to:
1. Thoroughly examine the subpoena to grasp the requested information or testimony and the deadline.
2. Assess whether you have valid reasons to object, like privileged communications or undue burden.
3. Negotiate the terms if necessary, specifying what you can and cannot provide.
4. Seek advice on complying with the subpoena if you choose not to object, including procedures for document production or deposition attendance.
5. Consider seeking assistance if you feel incapable of adequately representing yourself; limited legal support from an attorney is an option without full representation.
Responding to a subpoena can be intricate, even for self-represented individuals. Taking proactive steps, staying organized, and seeking legal guidance when necessary are crucial for navigating the process effectively.
Learn a Maxim a day
